CTO Proves AI Hasn’t Replaced Engineers: Human Value Remains Crucial

KeepAlerting CTO Shahar Glazner argues in a recent X post that while AI automates routine coding, human engineers remain indispensable. He asserts that humans are essential for solving complex system issues, making strategic decisions, and bearing final responsibility, shifting the role from executi

Back to news

Tech Insights AI 编辑Published Nov 18, 2026 88 views

Overview

Discussions on whether artificial intelligence (AI) will replace human engineers have recently resurfaced as a focal point in the industry. Against this backdrop, Shahar Glazner, Co-founder and CTO of KeepAlerting, published a long-form post titled "On Being an Engineer in 2026" on the social media platform X on November 9. Rather than promoting pure technological optimism or pessimism, the article employs a unique "proof by contradiction" logic to redefine the value of human engineers in the AI era.

配图

Glazner first acknowledges the prevalent sense of "loss of control" in the tech community. He notes that specific work tasks are periodically taken over by AI, a trend starting with non-coding jobs and gradually penetrating core development areas. However, his core argument is that despite AI's growing capabilities, human engineers are not being replaced but are becoming more important in certain aspects. By analyzing AI's limitations and the unique advantages of human engineers in complex systems, responsibility, and non-standardized problem-solving, he argues that "we still need engineers." This perspective offers a new line of thinking for anxious developers amidst the widespread adoption of AI tools.

插图1

Background

To understand Glazner's viewpoint, one must review the evolution of AI in software development over the past few years. Initially, AI was primarily used for auxiliary tasks such as code completion, documentation generation, or simple bug detection. These tools significantly boosted the productivity of junior engineers but also sparked concerns about the disappearance of entry-level positions. As large language models (LLMs) improved, AI began handling more complex logical units, even independently generating modular code snippets.

In this context, industry voices have become polarized. One side believes AI will quickly replace most coding work, reducing engineers to "prompt engineers" or simple code reviewers. The other side insists that the core of software engineering lies in architecture design, requirement analysis, and system integration, areas where AI struggles. Glazner's article sits at the center of this debate. He observes that while AI efficiently completes standardized, repetitive coding tasks, it often falls short when facing ambiguous requirements, cross-system integration issues, and decisions requiring a balance between business and technical trade-offs.

Furthermore, the takeover of "non-coding work" mentioned by Glazner reflects AI's strengths in automated processes, data analysis, and monitoring alerts. As a company specializing in Application Performance Monitoring (APM) and observability, KeepAlerting's tech stack relies heavily on automation and data analysis. Thus, Glazner's perspective is representative of the industry: in operations and monitoring, AI has indeed taken over many traditionally manual tasks. However, this does not signal the end of the engineer's role but rather a shift in focus from "execution" to "decision-making" and "optimization."

插图2

Impact

Glazner's viewpoint has profound implications for the gaming industry and software development as a whole. First, it alleviates professional anxiety while raising capability requirements. If AI handles standardized coding, human engineers' core competitiveness shifts to areas AI cannot easily mimic. This includes a deep understanding of business logic, the ability to abstract complex systems, and the courage to make decisions in uncertain environments. For game developers, this means creative implementation, player experience optimization, and cross-team collaboration are becoming more critical than ever.

Second, this perspective may reshape hiring and training strategies for technical teams. Companies may prioritize system design skills, problem-solving mindsets, and contributions to business value over coding speed or syntax proficiency. The training path for junior engineers may also change, requiring earlier exposure to architecture and business logic rather than just syntax practice.

Finally, from an industry ecosystem perspective, the普及 of AI tools lowers the barrier to software development, allowing more non-technical personnel to participate in product building. This simultaneously demands stronger integration capabilities from technical teams to ensure AI-generated code or modules are safely and efficiently incorporated into existing systems. Glazner's proof by contradiction reminds us that the ultimate goal of technological progress is not to replace humans but to enhance human capabilities. In 2026 and beyond, the value of human engineers lies not in competing with AI in calculation speed or code lines, but in using AI as a lever to solve truly complex, creative, and responsible problems. This shift will drive software engineering from "labor-intensive" to "intellect-intensive," bringing new growth points and innovative momentum to the industry.